The "several generations per day" idea again looked good on paper, I expect, but it would take far more than what we got to convince me that someone like Cobb who has almost certainly been alive for more than one day wouldn't know it hadn't been that long. If we'd seen some of the clone warriors ageing unnaturally fast, for instance...

Presumably the Hath weren't born with that remarkably unworkable-looking breathing apparatus grafted to their schnozzles. And if they need it to function in human-compatible atmospheres, then where's the Hath terraforming device, or how is this remotely a co-colonisation project?

There were good things in there somewhere, and I can look at Georgia Moffett till the cows come home (and probably after that: cows really don't compete) but there needed to be more, and my willingness to cut nuWho some slack evaporated a long time ago.